page contents Border Patrol agent found not guilty of murder in Mexican teen's 2012 death – The News Headline

Border Patrol agent found not guilty of murder in Mexican teen's 2012 death

José Antonio Elena Rodríguez used to be on Calle Internacional, 4 blocks from his house in Nogales, when 16 pictures punctured the night time. Ten bullets struck him, 8 within the again, two within the head. He died the place he fell.

The 16-year-old used to be now not a sufferer of boulevard crime. All of the pictures got here from the US, from the gun of a Border Patrol agent aiming in the course of the fence which separates Arizona from Mexico.

It used to be 10 October 2012, the date on which a tender existence ended and a intently watched felony saga started. A unmarried query threaded a circle of relatives’s grief and argument about border safety and america charter: used to be it homicide?

The agent, Lonnie Swartz, mentioned he fired in self-defence towards rock-throwing drug smugglers. Prosecutors mentioned the agent flippantly, intentionally and unlawfully took a existence, appearing as pass judgement on, jury and executioner, and that his uniform must now not protect him from justice.

On Monday, a jury in a federal court docket in Tucson, Arizona, discovered Swartz now not accountable of second-degree homicide and mentioned it might now not achieve a verdict on two lesser manslaughter fees.

Rodríguez’s grandmother left the court docket in tears.

Watchdogs and activists condemned the outcome. “These days’s verdict demonstrates the power stumbling blocks to duty in Border Patrol that stay, in particular on the subject of use of power,” mentioned the Kino Border Initiative, an advocacy team. It cited six other folks killed on Mexican soil by way of Border Patrol brokers.

“All of those that are chargeable for those deaths are unfastened from punishment, and not one of the sufferers nor their members of the family have ever been afforded a trail to justice.”

“Unimaginable … unpardonable,” tweeted Cronica Nogales, a Nogales blogger.

Swartz has been on unpaid depart since being indicted in 2015. The not on time trial started closing month and lasted 16 days. Swartz confronted 20 years to existence in jail if convicted of second-degree homicide.

The jury deadlocked closing Friday after 3 days of deliberations. America district pass judgement on Raner Collins advised jurors they might imagine voluntary manslaughter, with a most of 20 years in jail, or involuntary manslaughter, with a most of six years. Unanimity nonetheless proved elusive.

Prosecutors expressed unhappiness and mentioned they might imagine whether or not to hunt a recent trial for manslaughter.

Araceli Rodriguez, the mother of José Antonio Elena Rodríguez.



Araceli Rodriguez, the mummy of José Antonio Elena Rodríguez. : Zuma/Rex Shutterstock

There used to be no fast reaction from the Border Patrol or Rodríguez’s circle of relatives.

The case put a focus on whether or not america charter carried out to overseas voters on overseas soil and the tradition and insurance policies of Border Patrol ahead of and because Donald Trump turned into president.

Then again, a lot of the testimony targeted at the moments main as much as Swartz’s fusillade.

All sides agreed at the fundamental info: at round 11pm on 10 October 2012, two males climbed the border fence, adopted by way of two different males hauling bundles.

Cameras detected them and police and Border Patrol brokers replied to the scene. Some retrieved deserted bundles with 22lb of marijuana, value just about $18,000. Others, together with Swartz, faced two males straddling the 18toes fence. 3 other folks at the Mexican facet began throwing rocks on the brokers.

Some preliminary accounts mentioned Rodríguez used to be now not concerned and simply strolling house after taking part in basketball. He appreciated cloudy days, cookies and spending time together with his sisters, his mom, Araceli Rodríguez, advised the Parent in 2015. “Despite the fact that he’s now not right here he’s nonetheless my son in spirit, in soul, in ideas, in phrases.”

The prosecutors who sought to prison his killer permitted did throw rocks. However doing so didn’t pose a grave threat nor justify homicide, mentioned Wallace Kleindienst, an assistant US legal professional. He argued that Swartz used to be “bored to death” with other folks throwing rocks and opened fireplace to not “get rid of a danger” however “to get rid of a human being”.

It took the agent 34 seconds to drain his gun clip, transfer 45 toes, reload and fireplace 3 extra bullets.

In emotional testimony, Swartz mentioned he used to be apprehensive and fired after rocks looked as if it would hit a fellow agent and a police canine. “This has gotta prevent. Any person’s going to get harm,” he recalled pondering. He mentioned he geared toward what looked to be two “shadowy figures” throwing rocks. After the taking pictures, he mentioned, issues went “grey” and he vomited.

Sean Chapman, a defence attorney, mentioned rocks may kill and brokers had a proper to shield themselves. “Sure, a gun is extra tough than a rock, however brokers are authorized to reply in positive scenarios. That’s the mindset, that’s the way in which they’re skilled.”

Allegations of Border Patrol brutality have grown because the company ballooned from four,000 brokers within the 1990s to 21,000 brokers, making it one of the most Division of Place of origin Safety’s largest branches. Prosecutions are uncommon, convictions extra so.

Brokers imagine themselves america’s first line of defence towards bad drug and human traffickers.

Smugglers deploy youngsters to hurl grapefruit-sized rocks to intimidate and distract brokers, Vicente Paco, a Border Patrol spokesman, advised the Parent in 2016, indicating a rock-strewn roof in Nogales. “They select up pace and will do critical injury. If we commence getting rocked, we need to make split-second choices.”

The Border Patrol reported a pointy spike in attacks that 12 months. Then again, an investigation by way of The Intercept this week mentioned the company had manipulated statistics and that the task had by no means been more secure.

Trump, who needs to make bigger the company, blamed assailants closing November after two brokers had been discovered injured and subconscious in Texas. The FBI later concluded the likeliest clarification used to be an twist of fate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *