page contents Guns, cigarettes and prisons: Are Canada’s pension fund investments ethical? – The News Headline
Home / News Headline / Guns, cigarettes and prisons: Are Canada’s pension fund investments ethical?

Guns, cigarettes and prisons: Are Canada’s pension fund investments ethical?

OTTAWA – The federal Liberals are going to bat for the Canada Pension Plan Funding Board (CPPIB) amid moral issues over its funding portfolio.

Reality check: Is CPP going to be around when you retire?

“We predict the CPPIB, like different Crown firms, to are living as much as the absolute best requirements of ethics and behavior and that’s, if truth be told, precisely what it’s doing,” stated Finance Minister Invoice Morneau all over query length Monday within the Area of Commons.

The New Democrats challenged Morneau this week to weigh in on new moral questions surrounding the funding portfolio of the arms-length CPPIB – which manages masses of billions of greenbacks price of Canadians’ retirement financial savings.

WATCH: What adjustments to CPP imply for you (June 2016)

NDP MP Charlie Angus pressed Morneau for his opinion on CPPIB’s holdings in a tobacco corporate, an army guns producer and corporations that run non-public American prisons. The jail operators and their amenities are observed as beneficiaries of the Trump management’s arguable detention of asylum seekers and, in some instances, their kids.

Babies and toddlers sent to ‘tender age’ shelters under Donald Trump’s child separation policy

On Monday, Angus demanded Morneau give an explanation for whether or not he concept CPPIB’s investments in “cigarette corporations and privatized prisons” met a “credible usual of company funding” for the CPP.

Morneau responded that the pension supervisor, which oversees greater than $366 billion of CPP’s internet property, lives as much as the “absolute best requirements of ethics and behavior.”

WATCH: Apps that lend a hand Canadians save

Spoiler alert: The Canadian Press Baloney Meter is a dispassionate exam of political statements culminating in a rating of accuracy on a scale of “no baloney” to “stuffed with baloney” (whole method beneath).

Morneau’s observation by itself earns a ranking of “some baloney” – it’s most commonly correct however additional information is needed. Right here’s why.


CPPIB’s holdings in non-public U.S. jail operators CoreCivic Inc. and the GEO Team Inc. grew significantly between August 2017 and August 2018.

Over that length, the choice of GEO Team stocks held by way of CPPIB greater just about 13-fold to a worth of US$four.2 million, whilst its stocks of CoreCivic greater than doubled to a worth of US$1.76 million, in keeping with U.S. Securities and Trade Fee filings. CPPIB’s holdings within the jail corporations have been made public in a record remaining week by way of the Mother or father newspaper.

CoreCivic and GEO Team are anticipated to obtain primary trade boosts on account of the Trump management’s technique to coping with asylum seekers. The coverage has ended in the U.S. govt’s extremely contentious detention of fogeys and their kids.

WATCH: Shelters for detained kid migrants overcrowding in U.S. (June 2018)

Michel Leduc, CPPIB’s world head of public affairs and communications, stated the stocks within the two jail corporations have been obtained thru an set of rules that captures greater than three,000 corporations so as to diversify the fund’s portfolio.

“I wish to be crystal transparent about this: no CPPIB worker decided … to put money into the ones two corporations,” he stated in an interview, ahead of noting that many mutual price range and pension plans in Canada most probably include stocks within the jail companies as smartly.

Big pension funds and Ottawa look to partner and fund billions in infrastructure

He added that CPPIB is an lively supervisor in its primary investments in spaces like ports, electrical energy grids, toll roads and buying groceries centres. However the fund has a tendency to be passive in relation to its smaller holdings in publicly traded corporations.

Because of CPPIB’s measurement – it’s one of the crucial 10 biggest retirement price range on the earth – the worth of the jail corporate stocks make up best zero.001 according to cent of its general investments, he stated.

WATCH: Making plans for retirement at a tender age

The group, Leduc argued, takes satisfaction in its very top requirements in relation to moral, environmental and social issues. CPPIB additionally follows a strict coverage of best making an investment in companies that might be lawful in the event that they operated in Canada.

“The CPP Funding Board is observed world wide as one of the vital moral institutional traders on the earth,” he stated.

After Morneau defended the CPPIB on Monday within the Area of Commons, Angus criticized him day after today: “May just the finance minister give an explanation for what’s it about privatized American jail camps that he thinks represents any roughly moral funding usual?”

In his reaction Tuesday, Morneau looked as if it would tone down his place at the topic.

CPP Investment Board approached about Trans Mountain, CEO says no decision yet

“All Canadian Crown firms, all Canadian govt establishments are anticipated to are living as much as the absolute best requirements of moral behaviour and company governance. That comes with the Canada Pension Plan Funding Board,” Morneau stated.

“That is essential. We track it. We keep on best of it.”


Many mavens credit score CPPIB for having an excessively robust fashion in relation to accountable making an investment. However they argue it will pass even additional if it really sought after to keep away from making features from sure sorts of companies.

Tim Nash, a monetary planner and founding father of Excellent Making an investment, questions whether or not the for-profit U.S. prisons comply absolutely with Canadian regulations on account of the similar issues round human rights.

WATCH: Why ladies wish to save extra for retirement

He acknowledges CPPIB is the Canadian chief on sustainable funding insurance policies. However he additionally argues it’s now not the absolute best ranked globally.

“On this particular case, I might argue there’s a breach of the ones insurance policies and that, if truth be told, they aren’t residing as much as the ones absolute best requirements with the inclusion of those corporations throughout the funding portfolio,” stated Nash, who added the arguable nature of those jail operators – and the potential for court cases – raises the chance stage of the funding.

CPPIB steps into India’s real estate sector

“So far as I will be able to inform in relation to CPPIB’s particular funding coverage, they must now not be proudly owning those corporations.”

He stated CPPIB may just simply modify its technique to disregard some sorts of corporations – with out sacrificing monetary returns.

Lisa Kramer, a College of Toronto finance professor, stated so-called ESG making an investment ideas, which can be adopted by way of CPPIB, are a part of an rising space that’s nonetheless now not smartly outlined. ESG stands for environmental, social and governance.

“Socially accountable making an investment is regularly within the eye of the beholder relying on what ideas one holds pricey to her personal center,” stated Kramer, a professional on behavioural finance.

“It may be very tough to undertake an funding technique that makes everyone satisfied.”

Canada Pension Plan reform to boost assets above $15 trillion by 2090

Tessa Hebb, a Carleton College knowledgeable on accountable funding, credit CPPIB for having an excellent fashion of accountable making an investment.

However Hebb stressed out there’s a distinction between accountable making an investment and moral making an investment. Accountable making an investment makes a trade case for investments and is helping traders keep away from riskier choices.

WATCH: Saving on your long term and retirement 

Moral requirements, alternatively, are way more subjective, she stated.

“It’s attention-grabbing that Minister Morneau would use the time period ethics,” Hebb stated. “If he had stated that they have been one of the crucial best accountable traders – completely.”


On this case, Morneau stated CPPIB resides as much as the “absolute best requirements of ethics and behavior” as he spoke back to a query about its investments in U.S. jail corporations.

However whilst mavens say CPPIB is considered in some ways as a pace-setter in accountable making an investment, they argue figuring out moral requirements will depend on a person’s perspectives and will range very much.

Because of this, Morneau’s observation charges “some” baloney.


The Baloney Meter is a venture of The Canadian Press that examines the extent of accuracy in statements made by way of politicians. Each and every declare is researched and assigned a ranking in accordance with the next scale:

No baloney – the observation is totally correct

Just a little baloney – the observation is most commonly correct however additional information is needed

Some baloney – the observation is partially correct however essential main points are lacking

Numerous baloney – the observation is most commonly erroneous however accommodates parts of reality

Stuffed with baloney – the observation is totally erroneous

(serve as(d, s, identity) (file, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

About thenewsheadline

Check Also

Iran warns US against oil tanker seizure as ship leaves Gibraltar

Iran warns US against oil tanker seizure as ship leaves Gibraltar

Iran has warned the USA towards any new try to grasp an Iranian oil tanker …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *