page contentsTiger Woods and the problematic allure of redemption narratives – The News Headline

Tiger Woods and the problematic allure of redemption narratives

Get the Suppose publication.

By means of Dan Solomon

Tiger Woods gained his 5th Masters name on Sunday, a victory that got here greater than a decade after his remaining championship. So much has modified for the golfer — in all probability essentially the most well-known athlete on this planet — within the 11 years since he claimed victory on the 2008 U.S. Open. The 43-year-old’s triumph used to be celebrated from both sides — athletes and celebrities declared themselves impressed, President Donald Trump promised to award Woods the Presidential Medal of Freedom and paeans to the victor’s greatness had been written in gushing language. In each Time and the The New York Instances, the primary sentences of reports heralding Woods’s win incorporated a popularity of his luck in overcoming “non-public adversity.”

Woods did conquer either one of the ones issues. Professionally, he struggled as a competitor over a lot of the previous decade. He suffered a again damage that led to him to omit primary tournaments, and which can have resulted in his 2017 arrest for riding beneath the affect of prescription painkillers. Individually, after all, the “adversity” he overcame used to be a lot more sensational.


In 2009, the Nationwide Enquirer reported that he’d had an affair with a girl who labored as a VIP host at New York night time golf equipment, and the tale briefly developed from there — greater than a dozen girls got here ahead to allege that they, too, had had affairs with the golfer. There used to be a automobile coincidence, during which Woods crashed his Cadillac Escalade close to his area and used to be pulled from the car by means of his spouse. He used to be due to this fact dropped by means of various his high-profile sponsors. However no longer they all.

Any definition of the phrase “adversity” must come with Tiger Woods’s past due 2009 and early 2010, indubitably, however the way in which we use that phrase in describing sports activities heroes misses a large number of nuance. Once we discuss adversity within the context of sports activities, we nearly at all times deal with it as an exterior pressure — most cancers, the dying of a beloved one, excessive poverty, perhaps a significant and dramatic damage — and solid the athlete who battles it because the protagonist. We love our sports activities narratives to be blank morality performs. However informal observers are much more most likely to keep in mind Woods crashing his personal automobile right into a tree at 2 a.m. than they’re a string of again surgical procedures. The adversity Woods is legendary for overcoming, in different phrases, wasn’t one thing that took place to him. It used to be one thing that he did.

With regards to how we discuss sports activities, regardless that, our hero’s trips and redemption narratives are decidedly fed up in making that difference. That’s true relating to Woods, however he’s infrequently the primary instance. In sports activities media, “adversity” is flattened right into a generic impediment that, when it’s conquer, serves most effective to replicate even higher glory at the hero who triumphed over it.

The adversity Woods is legendary for overcoming, in different phrases, wasn’t one thing that took place to him. It used to be one thing that he did.

Remaining week, when the Baylor Girl Bears gained the NCAA Girls’s Basketball match, former NFL quarterback Robert Griffin III — one of the vital college’s maximum loved alumni — tweeted his congratulations the use of the body of overcoming adversity. “In the end @BaylorAthletics has been thru over the last few years, it’s cool to look the country have fun this Nationwide Championship with us,” he wrote — relating to the large sexual attack scandal that originated within the college’s soccer program in 2015.

After all, Baylor Athletics hadn’t such a lot “been thru” one thing horrible because it were accountable for one thing horrible. The college’s president, its athletics director and its head soccer trainer all both resigned or had been fired because of the scandal. But if the varsity claims a championship, it’s simple sufficient to solid all of that as simply the impediment that gives dramatic heft to the triumphant 3rd act.

In a similar fashion, in 2011, with the Pittsburgh Steelers at the verge of a Tremendous Bowl berth, a CNN tale highlighted quarterback Ben Roethlisberger’s “Street to Redemption,” a trail that began with a couple of sexual attack allegations and it seems that used to be paved basically by means of a handful of grasp performances at the box.

There’s reputedly no adversity that may’t be conquer by means of succeeding at the inexperienced, the courtroom, or the sphere.

There’s reputedly no adversity that may’t be conquer by means of succeeding at the inexperienced, the courtroom, or the sphere. The day after Kansas Town Chiefs linebacker Jovan Belcher murdered his daughter’s mom after which shot himself in entrance of 2 of the group’s coaches, a Sports activities Illustrated column in regards to the sport by means of venerable NFL creator Peter King used to be peppered with quotes from gamers about how “I might love to suppose perhaps I had some lend a hand, someplace, from No. 59,” as regardless that Belcher were the sufferer of a sad coincidence and no longer the offender of a murder-suicide that left his daughter an orphan.

The offenses above are indubitably graver than the slew of affairs that Woods admitted to in a televised observation in February 2010. Within the #MeToo technology, a well-known guy being introduced down by means of a string of consensual encounters with girls rather then his spouse turns out nearly old fashioned, like finding out that bicycles had been as soon as regarded as an indication of depravity.

So in the event you’re moved to cheer for Woods, by means of all manner, cross forward — however let’s no longer deal with the decisions he made as additional evidence of his greatness, or deal with his victory on Sunday as regardless that it erases his previous errors. We adore our dramatic sports activities narratives of triumph and glory, and we wish the victors to be worthy of them. Those tales are what give video games that means past a last rating. In the end, regardless that, the scoreboard doesn’t care how any one treats other folks. And we shouldn’t glance to it for steerage when deciding who has or has no longer been redeemed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *